I'll try and go in order, which may mean I cover some things twice, or maybe things won't always seem to flow as seamlessly as they might otherwise would.
Just to be sure I have put this first. Just so no on misunderstands me, and I think people understand this, but I am being cautious-I like Liniah. I don't dislike her, or think she is a bad person. I simply disagree with her in some areas. (We agree quite nicely in some areas.)
MooCow wrote:This is an excellent point. I've started a number of threads looking for information on european culture, government, etc. I never get much response.
Not many of the threads started on Europe get many replies from Europeans. I don't recall a thread about Australia at all, even though we have what I see as a pretty large number of Aussies on board.
lorg wrote:I don't really recall anything such threads, non that comes to mind right now. But if you want to I'm all for that. If you feel like discussing Europolitics I'll be there, anytime, anyplace, anywhere.
I'll keep that in mind!
As I see it we normally discuss news items and from them discussions spawn. We currently live in a very American centric world, after all we get a large dose of news about what happens in America etc, how much of what we do comes over to the other side? If we remove things related to America, terror, Iraq etc in some fashion how much is left then? I assume it won't be that much.
Hmm I've always felt the only limits on our conversations here are the ones we impose. I'd happily discuss nearly anything involving history-of which Europe, as a whole, has dominated most of.
I'd also welcome more discussion on Europe, but I honestly don't where to begin. America is easy for me. I live here. Europe is harder.
Isn't that just a another way of saying you suck. First you state that like you american goals and values and then you say Europe isn't America, ie it is not good but infact bad.
No! Let me apologize if thats the feel you get. TLM hit the nail on the head, in my opinion. America is changing its role in the world, just like European nations are as well. We're different-but different is no indication of good or bad, right or wrong.
I think the answer to quote Deev, is somewhere in the middle. Americans do bad things. Europeans do bad things. They both do good things. Why they do either is where we vary somewhat.
Does that make sense?
Twisted Sister" wrote:Paul, I think you underestimate the conflicting sense of awe along with the eyeball rolling condencension that your country is viewed in. Or at least you often don't hear the gasps of wonder as you're pouncing on those that find reason to snigger behind their hands for a moment
Yeah I agree. I would after all, I am an American Nationalist. I see the good in my nation. Add in that i don't have a real regular contact with the pulse of European politics,and what not, you're probably more on the mark than I would like to admit.
Everyone is negatively stereotyped in some way, so don't think you're special.
Oh I don't.
Liniah's finding out now exactly what the sterotypes are, and having to fight them. . She should be lauded for that, not dismissed.
I don't dismiss her, and to be honest I hadn't thought of it in that way. I didn't, and still kind of have a hard time seeing her as breaking stereotypes-but I can't deny thats possiblely true. (In fact is at least likely to be true at soem level.)
I've never outright dismissed her, or at least I don't think I have, and if I did sorry! I may differ with her in areas, or any of you in areas, but I also never take it for granted that I can learn from all of you.
You say that you have positive experiances in Europe...
Total aside here. I love SPAIN! We may continue...
...minus France. I know that for whatever reason, everyone has something against the French,but I am trying to find a Time article that goes into how close the US is in terms of culture with ze Froggies. As soon as I find it. I'll send it over to you.
I'd love to read it.
France was dirty, and I mean nasty dirty. Filth in the streets, rude people, even to each other. It was crumbling and over priced, and the few sights I wanted to see were crowded and just somehow not as nice as they were in say Portugal or Britain. Even Albania managed to be a nicer place to visit.
Sorry for the length peoples.
Liniah wrote:First off, I'm not representing myself as something other than I am. I have never lied about my nationality and never refused to admit my nationality or anything like that.
Actually that wasn't aimed at you Lin, sorry if you thought it was. That was more or less aimed at the idea introduced in the article of Americans who hide their nationality while overseas.
I would never do that. I don't see you as the type to do it either. Sorry for any confusion.
So, why exactly are you ashamed of me, Paul?
Well initially you posted this:
Liniah wrote:I take it as a compliment when Europeans don't think I'm American. Sure, I am American, but I don't act like the steryo-typical American, which I consider a very good thing. When people do call me American here, I tend to take it as an insult.
Anyone whose initial reaction is to be insulted or ashamed in that situation is what bothers me. Their, in my opinion, buying into the stereotype. Perpetuating it. And thats wrong.
That you're happy to not be perceived as an American bothers me. I don't see in it the same manner as you.